The iconic American hamburger, is there anything that is more quintessential to backyard entertaining? The hot dog? Ribs? Grilled local sustainable vegetables? Certainly not. I submit to you that it is the burger. I looked at the date of my last post and realized that I am a terrible blogger. C'est la vie. But I am inspired by the millions of burgers that will be ruined this coming Monday and decided to jot down a little overview of the burger.
Certainly the hamburger is not made of pork or ham. The implication is always ground beef unless stated otherwise. The name comes from it's historical origin, Hamburg in Germany. Now there are many claims as to who actually invented it and I'm not interested in that for our purposes today. My main points are that many people do not properly cook them well. I also feel that too many toppings have been taking away from the essence of the beef flavor. While I enjoy variation, I revel in well executed simplicity even more.
Childhood memories of the burger include McDonald's cheeseburgers and homemade burgers both grilled and pan fried. I haven't eaten at McDonald's in about 20 years; so it's been a long time. But I do remember a fully cooked, thin patty, that was donned with ketchup, mustard, pickles, and processed American Cheese. I thought it was good at the time. Hamburgers made at home offered little variation from this format.
I think the thing that automatically pops into the American mind these days is still much the same with the addition of possibly mayo, iceberg lettuce, and sliced tomato. But really, this is not a tasty combination. The bun is usually flavorless. A classic burger bun probably used to be genuine challah, or brioche that actually tasted of butter and eggs. (Not that I think the bun should dominate or be chewy. More on that later.) Tomatoes are not in season eleven out of the twelve months of the year, tasting anemic and essentially wasting space and money. Iceberg, while crunchy, is flavorless. Ketchup is generally overly sweet and under spiced. At least a classic yellow mustard and the pickles are generally zingy and flavorful despite their origin. And my biggest beef (pun intended), is that the burger is generally overcooked. Besides, with so many ingredients and lubricating condiments, the whole thing tends to slide apart upon actually eating the damned thing.
Let's start with the beef. There are many options out there. But right off the bat, I'm going to argue that you stop buying pre-ground beef,
unless you are at a store where you are confident that it is actually well trimmed meat that was ground on the same day. This all started one day, during my undergrad years, when I was at the store and the label on the beef said, "May contain ground beef from one or a combination of any of these countries: [the label then proceeded to list at least 10 countries, not even ones that were close to the US]." I realized that while I eat meat, I cannot rest easy eating a hamburger that started on several different continents. Besides, how many times can you remember breaking apart raw hamburger at home and realized that a nefarious butcher has wrapped darker, oxidized ground beef inside fresh ground beef. I am not anti-aging when it comes to beef. The best steaks are dry-aged but hamburgers are not the time for that.
And what cut of beef? There are many chefs and recipes that argue for sirloin, ribeye, chuck, round, even filet has been suggested. Madness all of it. I use 100% chuck 100% of the time. Here's why: It's affordable and also contains an optimal ratio of fat to meat. While I think the massively popular Food Network has educated us about this, many still use a mixture that is far too lean, easily overcooks, and is lacking the fat that is essential to that concentrated "beefy" flavor. Also, it's more expensive. Forgot to mention earlier that grinding beef can often save you money because you're taking that job away from the butcher. And if it's not and you're in a store where chuck costs more than ground beef you should maybe be asking yourself why that is? So buy yourself a nice chuck roast. It's also easy to cut it into strips and run it through your meat grinder.
Okay, then your home from the store with your chuck roast, buns or rolls of some type, and your condiments. Pop your chuck roast into the freezer for a few minutes while you put away groceries, set up your food grinder (We're going to assume one is using the KA stand mixer with grinder attachment.), and crack a beer or pop a bottle of wine. We put the meat into the fridge, not only because it just warmed up on its journey from the store, but meat also grinds better when it is cold. It's also a bit easier to cut it, especially if you only have pedestrian knives.
The KA grinder comes with two standard dies and you can use either of them, it's a matter of preference but if you use the large die, you have to run it through twice. Using the smaller one is easy, and you only have to run the meat through once. However it does create a grind that is easier to over compress when forming the patties, thus risking a dense burger. You don't want a dense burger. The large die creates a satisfying chew, but the burger falls apart a bit too easily. Thus you have to run it through again to develop the myosin proteins in the meat that will make it stickier. This will allow you to form burgers that have a better texture and hold together without you have to overwork the meat. Did you know you were conducting science experiments every time you made burgers?
Now you can have your grill pre-heated, or you can make these ahead of time and then grill later, even tomorrow. I actually find that, just like steak, it's easier to hit a consistent medium rare when the meat is at room temperature before I start. Yeah, I eat them medium rare, kind of gross for some, but I also devour steak tartar so I don't see the big deal. Most folks prefer medium and I don't stand at the grill taking orders about what temp you like yours. You're getting medium unless you request medium rare. Requests for overcooked burgers are ignored.
Take your chuck out of the freezer. It should be very cold to the point of just starting to freeze on the edges. Rinse if you like and pat dry. This is another junction to observe why grinding your own meat, as Martha would say, "A good thing". You can observe the whole muscle and know that it's not contaminated with anything unsavory. You could chop it up and eat it raw if the fancy strikes you. Also, you can be confident that it's the quality you need to enjoy a medium or medium rare burger. Another advantageous thing you can do is season the cut, pre-ground meat with your salt and pepper at this junction. This will result in seasoning throughout the entire burger, not just on the outside which tends to fall into the flames anyway. If you do choose to do it the old fashion way and just season the outside of the patties, do it ahead of time so that the salt has time to penetrate the meat.
Now there are those that might jump in at this point and argue that pre-salting will dry out your product and result in a less juicy burger. Rubbish. Moisture is extracted from the burger but the amount is negligible and the flavor trade-off you get more than makes up for it. Chuck is 20-30% fat and no amount of salt is going to pull out those chunks of fat that are going to be internally basting your burger when it hits the grill. But I digress.
Run the meat through the die, the large one twice or the smaller one once. You can also choose to season the meat at this junction in the bowl because you're going to mix it lightly with your fingers, but it's the less dependable junction ensure the most even salt distribution. You're going to mix the meat to distribute season but more importantly, you're distributing the fat. In chuck, the fat tends to be concentrated in big veins. After you grind it into a bowl, those are broken up but they're all still in one general spot and you don't want it all to go into only one or two burgers. Now with our fingers spread apart, and palms upward, LIGHTLY, run your hands down the side of the bowl and then LIGHTLY, pull them straight up. Rotate your bowl 90 degrees and do this a few times, just until the fat is evenly distributed throughout your ground beef. Do not overwork the meat or try to get it to form together. This is another reason why you wanted your chuck to be on the edge of frozen, it helps to evenly mix everything without forming an emulsion. By the way, Gyro meat is the exact opposite; it's a dense emulsion of meat called forcemeat.
Now to form the burgers, I use a scale. I know that that may seem to be a bit anal compulsive to some, but I like the precision and if I know how many burgers I need, I can simply divide the ounces of ground meat by the number of burgers to get a precise estimate of how many ounces each burger need be. However, I generally know way ahead of time how many I'm going to make and I buy exactly that much chuck at the store. Also, since I go to so much trouble, I generally make more than I need and then vacuum seal and freeze two patties together. (Side by side, not on top of each other unless they're separated by parchment.) I make my regular burgers 8 oz. each and my sliders are, gulp, 4 oz. each which is probably the size a normal burger should be. Let's not discuss that. Also, by using a 1/4 c. measuring cup I generally get a very satisfying fat little (by that I mean big) slider that weighs 4 oz. For the regular size burgers, place a bowl or plastic wrap on the scale, tare the weight back to 0, then I pile the still fairly loose meat until it weighs 8 oz. the THEN, ONLY THEN, I form the patties. This should only be done 1) once, 2) lightly, and 3) quickly. You want a nice big disc that is just slightly larger than the bun so that when it cooks and shrinks to the size of the bun. Some people squeeze a dimple into the center of the patty so that when it cooks the burger is flat, but even my OCD doesn't go that far despite how busy it is inside my head.
Now there is variation that you can use at this point: you can put your cheese INSIDE the burger. Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat?!?! I'm sure that most have seen this kind of burger offered at restaurants and bars. I'm proud to say that this was invented in my college stomping grounds, and the land I will return to someday to buy a house, the Twin Cities. It's called a Jucy Lucy [
sic] or a Juicy Lucy and there is an intense
rivalry between two bars in south Minneapolis about the credit for inventing and the spelling. Anyway, it's kind of gimmicky but it's a gimmick that works.
I do not like cheese that is overly melted and running off the burger. A lot of flavor is lost this way as the cheese runs into the flames or simply absorbs into the bun. I don't like having to bother with cheese at the last minute timing the temperature of the burger and the melting time needed by the cheese. My favorite is when the cheese is just sweating and JUST starting to bend around the burger. Warm but not runny. So when you put the cheese inside the burger, this kind of happens automatically depending on the temperature. If you like melted cheese AND medium rare this is not going to work. And for those who like well done and melty cheese, rejoice your cheese is contained and none is lost to the flames! It also works very well when you want to use crumbly Feta or blue cheese as the crumbles don't roll off the top. (Ina Garten actually puts a pat of butter in the middle of her burgers. I've done it and it works great if you're using leaner meat. Bit of overkill if you're already working with fatty chuck.) To execute this wonder of burger lore, simply form (2) 4 oz. patties and sandwich the cheese in the middle leaving a 1/2" margin with no cheese on the edges. Use the margin to seal the cheese so that it reduces the chances of your cheese running out.
Back to the process. If you haven't seasoned your meat yet, do so now and give the salt a few minutes to dissolve into the meat. No use salting and immediately throwing it onto the grill only to have the salt & pepper sacrifice itself to the grilling gods. I also like to brush the patties with a light coating of olive oil. This does two things: 1) Helps to avoid sticking to the grill and 2) promotes browning which is important for both flavor and visual presentation. Wow, it is a busy place in my head. I'm well over 2,000 words and haven't gotten those darn patties on the grill yet.
Onward to the fire, comrades. There are many opinions about grilling so I won't spend time dissing (Yeah, I said 'dissing'. What you gonna do about it?) others revered traditions. I'll just describe how I do it. Now, I'm sorry if you don't own a
Big Green Egg grill, but I do. They're getting more and more popular every year but I've had mine for eight years. I also replaced the original grid with a cast iron cooking grid. I L-O-V-E it. It seasons just like a cast iron pan, forming a natural nonstick surface. It has much greater weight than the normal stainless steel, thus retaining much more heat. And it produces excellent grill marks that are both larger and further apart. Makes your burgers look like they came right out of a steakhouse commercial. The char or the burn also adds flavor that I personally like. I get my grill rocket hot to make sure that the cooking grid is thoroughly heated through. This both produces grill marks and helps to prevent sticking. So I let it rip for like 20-30 minutes before I even begin. The thermometer generally reads about 500-600 degrees. I use direct heat only because the high temperature generally cooks the burgers through before they burn. You may have to use a combination of direct and indirect heat on your grill.
Ummmhhh, have we started grilling yet? So your grill is rocket hot, commence. Put your burgers on the grill, you might get some minor flare ups but don't panic yet. Put the top back on the grill and leave your burgers alone for two minutes at least. Grilling is like faith; you have to believe it's happening without a whole bunch of questions. Grilling with the lid is going to reduce flare ups, which imparts a nasty chemical taste, and it also helps the burger to cook internally faster. We're racing to get the middle done with just enough char on the outside. It's an art form that you need to practice. I absolutely hate watching people grill burgers with the lid off, poking, fussing, moving, pressing (Do NOT press your burgers!), and generally worrying.
Now depending on the temperature of the grill, you can check them. Careful taking the lid off, it's gonna encourage flare ups. (And careful raising the lid on the BGE. If the thermometer is greater than 500F and you raise it too quickly, it will cause a flashback, igniting the oxygen around the grill and singing all the hair off your forearms and possibly your eyebrows. This has happened to me a couple times and it's not a joke. But then most BGEers know how to "burp" their grill to prevent this.) Flip your burgers once, just once. If you didn't fuss and move your patties about and your grill was rocket hot, you will have beautiful char lines. If your burgers stick, leave them alone until they go through the
sticking "curve" and release. Don't panic and try to scrape it off the grill as you will do more damage than good. Also, still being stuck to the grill is an indication that your grill isn't as awesomely hot as mine and the burger isn't cooking quickly. So you've flipped. Time to go back to the faith of grilling and put the lid back on. Do not press your burgers. It does cook them faster by pressing out the blood and juices, but it causes flare ups and it does produce a less juicy burger. Not good. A minute or so before they're done, put your cheese on if you haven't executed the Juicy Lucy.
The buns. Any bun will do but I've really been on to onion rolls lately. They make a great onion roll at a local grocery store here in Chicago that is the marriage of sweet Hawaiian bread and the onion roll and I think it's absolutely perfect. I've also been using the regular King's Hawaiian rolls for my sliders. The flavor complement is great. Other great choices would be challah, brioche, or the currently popular pretzel bun. English muffins also work very well. So there's a few ways to skin a cat, but my favorite trick is to take all the buns out of the bag, put the burger in the bun and then put the burgers in their rolls back into the bag. Twist the bag securely shut and rest the burgers for 2-5 minutes. This rests the actual burger meat so that the juices don't come bursting out upon biting into it, and it perfectly steam heats the buns. You can also brush each bun with butter and warm it on the grill but it's much less convenient than the steam method. Besides, my burgers are already so flavorful, and I'm def going to slather on some mayo, that I've found that the buttered roll is a bit much. Even if you don't use the steam method, you still want the burgers to rest covered for a few minutes. Same as steak, they're going to finish cooking a bit more and the juices in the meat will slow down so they won't run out of the meat as readily.
There are infinite condiments and toppings to put on your burger so we won't discuss that in detail here. But I challenge you this: try to stick to three additions counting the cheese. A current favorite of mine is Havarti, sliced olives, and mayo. I like to put the sliced olives under the melted cheese because they fall off so easily. And I leave you with one burger recipe, that is not mine. It originated in Minneapolis at
Cafe Barbette where I spent way too much time and money . . . but none that I regret. I hope you enjoy your holiday this year with a better burger.
The Royale with Cheese
- English muffins, preferably homemade or Bays sourdough
- butter
- ground beef seasoned with salt, pepper, and fresh thyme
- Brie, preferably triple cream, such as Affinoix
- Caramelized onions
- 2-3 yellow onions (1 lb.)
- butter and olive oil
- S & P
- fresh thyme
- sugar
Make the onions well ahead of time. In any large, heavy pan with a lid, heat 1 T each of butter and olive oil. Put the onions, thinly sliced, in the pot and sprinkle in 1/8 t. sugar, 1/4 t. salt, 1/8 t. of freshly ground. Stir so that all the onions are evenly coated with the oil and the seasonings are distributed. Cover tightly and cook, without stirring or peeking, for about 45 minutes over the lowest possible heat. The onions will be soft and have released much of their liquid. Raise the heat, keep the lid off, and stir the onions frequently until they are a deeply golden color and the mixture begins to resemble a jam. Add 1 medium garlic clove, minced, and 1/2 t. fresh thyme leaves. Cook for three more minutes until the garlic is done. Set aside to cool to room temperature. (Onion jam recipe from The Bread Bible, by Rose Levy Beranbaum)
Make the burgers. Include about 1/2 t. of fresh thyme leaves/1 lb. of beef in the grinding process, or mix it in if you have pre-ground meat. Season and grill as you normally would. At the very last minute, top the burgers with the Brie to warm it. It's very runny and easy to melt so watch closely
Butter and grill the muffins. The steaming method is not preferable with English muffins. Spread a layer of the onion jam on the bottom muffin, place the cheeseburger, and optionally spread a layer of mayo on the top half of the muffin. Bon Appetit.